Shoulder Surgeon on Long Island
A baseball player with a SLAP tear, an active adult with shoulder impingement, or someone with arthritis can all experience shoulder pain, but their treatments shouldn’t look the same.
That’s why Dr. James Maguire develops personalized treatment plans based on your lifestyle, diagnosis, and goals. If you’re ready to get out of pain and move with strength and confidence again, book an appointment today.
SHOULDER CONDITIONS
Shoulder pain can develop suddenly after an injury or gradually over time because of arthritis, repetitive motion, or normal wear and tear. As an orthopedic shoulder surgeon on Long Island, Dr. Maguire diagnoses and treats a wide range of shoulder conditions, including:
Rotator Cuff Tears
Shoulder Arthritis
Frozen Shoulder
Shoulder Impingement Syndrome
Shoulder Bursitis
Shoulder Dislocation
Shoulder Instability
Labral Tears
SLAP Tears
Biceps Tendinitis
AC Joint Arthritis
Bankart Lesion
Ligament Sprains
Collarbone & Shoulder Fractures
Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
Osteonecrosis
SHOULDER TREATMENT
Not all shoulder injuries require surgery, and many conditions improve with conservative treatment.
That’s why Dr. Maguire takes the time to thoroughly evaluate your shoulder, understand your symptoms and goals, and identify the underlying cause before recommending the most appropriate course of care. Surgery is only considered when it offers the best opportunity for lasting pain relief and restored function.
Depending on your condition, your individualized treatment plan could include one or more of the following:
Our Procedures
When conservative treatments are no longer providing relief or surgery offers the best path to recovery, Dr. Maguire specializes in advanced arthroscopic and shoulder replacement procedures.
He brings his sports medicine training to every case in order to restore strength and stability, alleviate pain, and help patients get back on the field, court, or their everyday activities as quickly as possible.
Arthroscopic shoulder surgery allows Dr. Maguire to treat many shoulder conditions while minimizing disruption to healthy tissue. Through a few small incisions, he uses a tiny camera and specialized instruments to repair damaged structures. Compared to traditional open surgery, shoulder arthroscopy may result in less post-operative pain, less scarring, and a faster recovery for many
A torn rotator cuff can make lifting your arm, reaching overhead, and even sleeping difficult. Dr. Maguire performs rotator cuff repair surgery using the latest arthroscopic techniques to address torn tendons or muscles and improve shoulder function and flexibility.
Labral tears and SLAP tears are common among athletes who participate in overhead sports such as baseball and volleyball. Arthroscopic labral repair surgery restores shoulder stability while helping patients safely return to sports and everyday activities.
For patients who experience recurrent shoulder dislocations or instability, arthroscopic stabilization procedures repair damaged ligaments and soft tissues to improve shoulder function and reduce the risk of future dislocations.
When severe arthritis or irreparable joint damage causes chronic pain and stiffness, shoulder replacement surgery may provide lasting relief. Dr. Maguire performs partial, total, and reverse shoulder replacement procedures using modern techniques designed to help patients regain comfort, strength, and stability with less downtime.
WHY DR. MAGUIRE
Dr. Maguire has advanced fellowship training in sports medicine and specialized experience in treating sports injuries, shoulder instability, rotator cuff tears, and complex shoulder conditions.
Dr. Maguire typically starts with non-surgical treatment. He only recommends surgery when patients have exhausted the conservative options or surgery would provide the best outcome.
Every shoulder injury (and every patient) is different. Treatment recommendations are tailored to your diagnosis, activity level, goals, and lifestyle.
Whenever possible, Dr. Maguire uses minimally invasive techniques to reduce tissue disruption and support a faster recovery and safe return to activity.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Our comprehensive approach is designed to provide clarity, comfort, and confidence from your first consultation to your final follow-up. We believe in a collaborative journey where you are empowered to take control of your health.
01
At your initial appointment, Dr. Maguire will perform a thorough evaluation to identify the source of your pain or injury. He’ll take the time to understand your symptoms, goals, and lifestyle. When appropriate, he may recommend diagnostic imaging such as X-rays or an MRI.
02
Once a diagnosis is made, Dr. Maguire will explain your treatment options and work with you to develop an individualized plan that fits your expectations and needs. Depending on your condition, treatment may include physical therapy, interventional pain management, or orthopedic surgery.
03
Dr. Maguire will guide you through every stage of recovery with a personalized rehabilitation plan. The goal is to help you heal safely, restore strength and mobility, and get back to performing your best.
Small or partial rotator cuff tears can often improve with conservative treatment, such as physical therapy and injections. Surgery could be required for larger or complete tears, especially if pain and weakness interfere with daily activities.
Shoulder arthroscopy is a minimally invasive procedure that involves making very small incisions and inserting an arthroscope (a tube-shaped instrument) that contains a small video camera and light.
The camera is connected to a monitoring system that lets Dr. Maguire visualize the joint in incredible detail on the screen without having to open up the shoulder completely. He then uses specialized instruments to repair the damage.
Absolutely. Dr. Maguire has advanced training in sports medicine and gained experience treating athletes at all levels of competition, including professional sports, collegiate athletics, and high school teams.
He participated in medical coverage for organizations such as the Baltimore Ravens and Baltimore Orioles during his fellowship at MedStar Georgetown University.
From baseball shoulder injuries to fractures, he helps athletes recover safely and return to play with confidence.
A SLAP tear is a specific type of labral tear that occurs at the top of the shoulder socket, where the labrum connects with the bicep tendon.
Other types of labral tears include a Bankart lesion, which occurs at the lower part of the labrum and, less commonly, a posterior labrum tear, which involves damage to the back of the shoulder socket.
Any type of labral tear can cause pain, instability, and reduced shoulder function.
Most patients do not require shoulder replacement. Shoulder replacement surgery is typically only recommended when conservative treatments no longer provide relief and arthritis or joint damage significantly affects quality of life.
If shoulder pain lasts more than a few weeks, limits your ability to work, exercise, play sports, or sleep, or follows a traumatic injury, it’s a good idea to schedule an evaluation with a shoulder specialist like Dr. James Maguire.
GET BACK IN THE GAME
Don’t let an injury or pain stand in your way. Dr. Maguire is here to help you understand your options and create a treatment plan tailored to your needs.
If you’re ready to get back in the game and move with strength, stability, and confidence again, schedule an appointment at our Long Island orthopedic office.
© 2026 OrthoMed Long Island. All rights reserved. Site by Becca Jules & Co.
